Harrison Bergeron by Kurt Vonnegut – A Short Story Review

I picked up this 475 page book from the Boston Public Library explicitly to read Kurt Vonnegut’s “Harrison Bergeron”. I quickly found out that this story was only 7 pages long. I’m sure I could have found a pdf version or an ebook version somewhere online instead of carrying home a 475 page book only to read a 7 page story. Oh well.

Vonnegut’s Harrison Bergeron reminded me a lot of the movie “Idiocracy”. The difference was that in Idiocracy the human race had de-evolved whereas in Vonnegut’s story (year 2081), there was a government officer entitled, “United States Handicapper General” who was responsible for making everyone equal in every conceivable way. People were given masks that were inversely proportional to their good or bad looks. Those that were more athletic were given sacks of birdshot to wear around their necks. The more athletic you were, the heavier your sack of birdshot was. People with good sight were given glasses to blur their vision and people with bad sight were given glasses to improve their vision. The list went on, basically everyone was some level of mediocre talent, intelligence, and attractiveness, finally reaching a state of human equality (or something).

image

Reading Harrison Bergeron by Kurt Vonnegut in my living room.

About the Author Kurt Vonnegut:

Kurt Vonnegut (1922-2007) is one of the most beloved American writers of the twentieth century. Vonnegut’s audience increased steadily since his first five pieces in the 1950s and grew from there. His 1968 novel Slaughterhouse-Five has become a canonic war novel with Joseph Heller’s Catch-22 to form the truest and darkest of what came from World War II.Vonnegut began his career as a science fiction writer, and his early novels–Player Piano and The Sirens of Titan–were categorized as such even as they appealed to an audience far beyond the reach of the category. In the 1960s, Vonnegut became closely associated with the Baby Boomer generation, a writer on that side, so to speak.

Now that Vonnegut’s work has been studied as a large body of work, it has been more deeply understood and unified. There is a consistency to his satirical insight, humor and anger which makes his work so synergistic. It seems clear that the more of Vonnegut’s work you read, the more it resonates and the more you wish to read. Scholars believe that Vonnegut’s reputation (like Mark Twain’s) will grow steadily through the decades as his work continues to increase in relevance and new connections are formed, new insights made.  (Courtesy of Amazon.com)

Check out some of the other books I’ve read on Shelfari.com:

A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings by Gabriel Garcia Marquez – A Short Story Review

A Very Old Man with Enormous WingsA Very Old Man with Enormous Wings by Gabriel García Márquez

My rating: 4 of 5 stars

The story was incredibly short (9 pages with large font) so I finished most of it before I even boarded my morning train to work. The story involved a couple who found a very old man with enormous wings laying on the ground in their back yard. He seemed battered, tired, and old with wings that were falling apart and filled with parasites. Not quite sure what to do, the couple consulted a neighbor who told them it was an angel who had fallen from the sky and that it should be clubbed to death. The couple decided not to club it to death but instead they locked it in their chicken coop until they really figured out what to do with it. Townspeople soon got word that there was an angel in their chicken coop so they came by in masses to poke it, throw rocks at it, and mock it from afar. The angel seemed only to possess the virtue of patience because he hardly noticed the people who were poking him and mocking him.  They said that he had wings more like a vulture than an angel and a priest came by to profess that he was indeed not an angel because he didn’t speak latin, the supposed language of God. Some people came looking for miracles but only received sub-par miracles such as a blind man who was not cured of his blindness but rather grew three new teeth instead.

At one point the couple thought about putting the old man with the enormous wings in a raft with three days worth of food and sending him out on the ocean. However, they realized that they could actually profit from him being in their chicken coop. Soon enough, the couple started charging admission to see the “angel”. With the money they earned they built a two story mansion but the stench of the chicken coop and the presence of the very old man with enormous wings was still infringing on their new life. At the end of the story, the angel seemed to have recovered what little strength he could and he flew away and that’s where the story ended.

What I took from this story was that the angel was indeed testing the couple. Would they clothe him because he was naked, would they feed him because he was hungry, and would they heal him because he was sick? The answer was to all three of those questions was no. They did not give him clothes, the townspeople tried to force feed him mothballs, and they did nothing to try and heal him. They simply tossed him in the chicken coop and were only concerned with making a profit off his existence. After the couple built their mansion the angel knew that the test was over, they failed, so he got up and flew away. I’m sure there are many other interpretations fo this story but that’s what I got out of it.

View all my reviews on GoodReads.com

Typing up my review of "A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings" on the train coming home from work.

About the Author Gabriel Garcia Marquez:

Gabriel José de la Concordia García Márquez (Spanish pronunciation: [ɡaˈβɾjel ɡaɾˈsia ˈmaɾkes]; born March 6, 1927 ) is a Colombian novelist, short-story writer, screenwriter and journalist, known affectionately as Gabo throughout Latin America. He is considered one of the most significant authors of the 20th century. He was awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1982, and is the earliest winner of this prize who is still alive. He pursued a self-directed education that resulted in his leaving law school for a career in journalism. From early on, he showed no inhibitions in his criticism of Colombian and foreign politics. In 1958, he married Mercedes Barcha; they have two sons, Rodrigo and Gonzalo. He started as a journalist, and has written many acclaimed non-fiction works and short stories, but is best known for his novels, such as One Hundred Years of Solitude (1967) and Love in the… READ MORE. (courtesy of Amazon.com)

The Snows of Kilimanjaro by Ernest Hemingway – A Short Story Review

The Snows of Kilimanjaro and Other Stories (Scribner Classics)The Snows of Kilimanjaro and Other Stories by Ernest Hemingway

My rating: 4 of 5 stars

The Snows of Kilimanjaro was certainly an interesting story. Hemingway wrote of a man (a writer) dying of gangrene on an African safari accompanied by his rich wife. The man had scraped his leg just days earlier but because he neglected to clean it out properly he ended up getting gangrene and was dying on a cot as the story began. Hemingway developed his character through conversation and flashbacks which seems to be pretty consistent with his other books that I have read. He goes into quite a lot of detail about the wife and her past as a rich woman who had many lover.  He goes into minimal detail about the dying man but let’s his conversation, mostly consisting of cutting remarks to his wife and flashbacks of regret, drive his character development. As he lay there dying he regretted many things in his life but mainly he regretted not being able to write everything down. He had spent his whole life waiting to write things down in hopes that he would know more about the world when it was time to write. However, the end of his life came sooner than he anticipated, teaching the lesson that life is short and fragile and should be lived every day to the fullest.

View all my reviews on GoodReads.com

I read this book to and from work on the train. It was 29 pages long so I was able to finish it easily, even with a 10 minute nap on the ride home from work.

About the Author Ernest Hemingway:

Born in Oak Park, Illinois, in 1899, Ernest Hemingway served in the Red Cross during World War I as an ambulance driver and was severely wounded in Italy. He moved to Paris in 1921, devoted himself to writing fiction, and soon became part of the expatriate community, along with Gertrude Stein, F. Scott Fitzgerald, Ezra Pound, and Ford Madox Ford. He revolutionized American writing with his short, declarative sentences and terse prose. He was awarded the Nobel Prize for Literature in 1954, and his classic novella The Old Man and the Sea won the Pulitzer Prize in 1953. Known for his larger-than-life personality and his passions for bullfighting, fishing, and big-game hunting, he died in Ketchum, Idaho, on July 2, 1961. (Courtesy of Amazon.com)

April 2011 – Short Story Reviews on my Train Commute

Since I moved into Boston and decided to rely 100% on public transit to commute to work, I’ve poured through dozens of books traveling to and from work.  I typically rotate between a classic, an adventure novel, and a business-esque book.  I can usually get in about 45 minutes to an hour of reading every day when you count in waiting for and riding on the trains.  Thinking back on it, I never would have read so many books if I were driving to and from work instead of taking the train.  Who has the time to drive an hour to work, spend 8-10 hours working, drive an hour home, eat, read books, AND have a life?  I’m not sure it’s possible so I definitely feel fortunate to be able to take the train to work every day.  Despite the shortcomings and frustrations associated with the MBTA, it still beats the hell out of when I used to drive to work, often stuck in Boston traffic for two hours per day.  That amounts to ten hours per week and 520 hours per year (equivalent of ~21 full days per year, ugh).

I’ve read a lot of diverse books but through talking with an old roommate of mine (double major in Economics and Classics) I realized that I’ve totally avoided the realm of short stories albeit unintentionally.  So I decided that this month’s 30 day life experiment would be to read and review one short story each day on my commute to work.  This should be a good way to put 20 new short stories in my repertoire.

To kick off this month’s experiment, I headed to the Boston Public Library.  I talked to a few different librarians and they were super stoked on my concept.  They printed off a list of popular short stories for me plus adding a few of their personal favorites not on that list.  The list was entitled, “The 50 Best Short Stories of All Time”.  I feel like with a title like that I can’t lose.  The stories were binned into various themes such as: Sad and Shocking, Pop Culture Classics, Modern Writers, Twist Endings, etc.  I plan to not repeat any authors as a way to get a diverse experience, then after this month is over I can go back and selectively pursue authors that I liked.

Over the past two years I’ve kept track of my books through a few different virtual bookshelves online.  I used Virtual Bookshelf for a while which integrated well with Facebook but then they went out of business so I switched to Goodreads.com.  I’ve been using Goodreads for about a year, writing short reviews on most of the books I finish.  There are a few other popular virtual bookshelves that I plan to investigate throughout thsi month such as Shelfari by Amazon, Delicious Library, Library Thing, and a few others.


As with all of my life experiments thus far, I’ll be keeping a Twitter List of users associated with short stories and literature in general.  Join the conversation HERE.